FSA’s vs. HSA’s: Which is better?
FSA’s vs. HSA’s: Which is better?
Although it’s certainly never your goal to get sick and incur medical expenses, it happens to everyone on some level. Whether it’s something as “small” financially as a prescription for your ear infection, or something as “large” financially as a major surgery or chemotherapy, no individual can escape 100% healthy. So, what are some ways to alleviate those medical financial woes? Options include both a medical flexible spending account (FSA) or a health savings account (HSA).
What’s the big difference?
FSA’s are workplace accounts where money is deducted from your gross income, reducing your taxable income, that can be used toward some out-of-pocket medical costs, including insurance copays and prescriptions. HSA’s are only available to individuals with qualifying high-deductible health plans, but contributions are tax-deductible and withdrawals for eligible medical costs are tax-free.
How do I contribute and how much can I contribute?
FSA contributions will come directly out of your paycheck into your account, whereas HSA contributions can be taken out of your paycheck if through your employer, but they can also be made directly by you from your net income and deducted when you file taxes.
As far as the amount you can contribute annually, both are based on inflation. In 2016, FSA contributions could not exceed $2,550 and HSA contributions were limited to $3,350 for individuals and $6,750 for families. For HSA’s though, you can contribute an additional $1,000 if you are 55 or older.
How do I utilize the funds?
FSA’s usually require providing medical receipts to your employer, which you will then be reimbursed for. Some companies offer FSA debit cards, but you may still be asked to provide receipts. HSA’s typically have debit cards linked to your account, but you will still want to document the expenses for tax purposes.
What if I don’t use it all?
FSA’s operate with a “use-it-or-lose-it” mentality. If you don’t utilize all the funds by the end of your benefits period, your employer will pocket the money unless they have a rollover option or grace period. HSA funds have no deadlines for withdrawal, and can even be invested in other funds and used for qualifying medical expenses tax-free, however, if you are under 65 and use the funds for non-medical expenses, you will be taxed, maybe even an additional 20%.
So, it may be tough to say one is better than the other as it really comes down to what you are eligible for in terms of your health plan, as well as what sort of medical spending account your employer may/may not offer. There are certainly pros and cons to both types, and you should, as always, research your options before investing.
About the Author
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
Related Articles
How the One Big Beautiful Bill Could Save Small Business Owners Millions When Selling
President Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill (OBBB) significantly expanded the benefits of the Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS), which could save owners millions in capital gains taxes. This is quietly reshaping how business owners think about selling their...
Financial Security Starts With an Emergency Fund. How To Build One (And Where To Keep It Safely)
An emergency fund is a safety net for when life happens. A job loss, a car breakdown, an unexpected medical expense. These costs can hit out of nowhere, so an emergency fund is one of the smartest financial tools you can have. It provides breathing room when things go...
Tax Changes Under Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill: What’s New in 2025 and Beyond
President Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill (OBBB) implements tax changes designed to simplify filing and keep more earnings in Americans’ pockets. The law adjusts how the IRS treats certain types of income, updates annual gift limits, raises the estate tax exemption,...
